Friday, March 1, 2013

Peer Review

Peer review has a new meaning to me now than before.  That phrase used to have a negative connotation when I heard it but now I have come to realize the effectiveness of peer review.  Before I always thought of it as an opportunity of someone to downplay someone's hard work.  Now I see it was an opportunity to help and receive help some others.  A mutual service in a sense.  The reviewer has the responsibility to correct and advise the essay he is reviewing and in turn he learns about writing style and has just helped someone improve their essay.  The same is for the writer, to be able to recieve critical responses lets us see our essay from a different perspective and thus improve the clarity and strength of it.  I enjoyed the opportunity to review my peer's essays and have mine reviewed as well.  I found that I had overlooked many key points and grammatical errors that I would have overwise overlooked.  I always try to be open to critizism, even the negative and unproductive ones.  The same responsibilities of a reader and writer apply here in which we must take account for bias and try to get the positive side of the critizism.  "Take everything with a grain of salt" I always heard growing up, look for the best in everything.  This is why I believe attitude plays a big part in peer review.  In conclusion, I found peer review effective and rewarding.

3 comments:

  1. Peer review has new meaning to me since this course as well. I never was a huge fan of peers reviewing my papers but I feel the reviews we have done have been very constructive and helpful. I really think peer review is helpful.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is pretty crazy how from high school to college the meaning of peer review changes 100 percent. I also agree now that it is very useful.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I loved that you highlighted the responsibilities of both the critiquer and the writer. There is much to be said for a careful critique, as well as someone who is willing to listen to the counsel given by peers!

    ReplyDelete